Published Mar 18 2010 by Infosphere AB

New Israeli-Palestinian peace-talks can they deliver?

The short answer is: probably not. At least not in the short run.

After a nearly a year of constant prodding and numerous trips by US officials, Israelis and Palestinians have finally agreed to resume peace-talks. These are not real negotiations however, but indirect talks with US mediators (most likely President Obama?s Special Envoy George Mitchell) shuttling between the parties in Jerusalem and Ramallah with proposals. Since this set-up is a step back to the kind of talks that the parties had before a more solid peace-process came about after the Oslo-agreements, it is a tell-tale sign of how deep the mistrust and resentment between the parties has gone. Peace-talks between the Israelis and the Palestinians have been in the deep-freeze since the Gaza war a year ago and the truth is that no one really believes any progress will come out of these talks.

Both sides have pre-conditions ? which they admittedly have set aside, for now at least ? that make progress even less likely. Even though both sides have signed on to the two-state solution, the way to achieve this and the end-goal of what a Palestinian state should look like, is still issues where there is no agreement. The Israeli government with Premier Netanyahu insists on a de-militarized state and with Israeli presence on its future eastern border to prevent imports of weapons and rockets that could endanger Israeli towns and cities. Both are conditions that no Palestinian administration could conceivably agree to. As for the Palestinian government under President Abbas, his insistence on a total settlement.-freeze before any final agreement could be signed is going nowhere. The fact that Abbas has agreed to even indirect talks without that condition being fulfilled leaves him in a vulnerable position vis-�-vis his own constituency. On the very same day that talks were announced, the Israeli government approved new settlements on the occupied West Bank, thus adding to the already tense situation. And a few days later, when US Vice President Joe Biden came visiting, Israel?s Interior Minister ? Eli Yishai ? announced approved plans for 1600 new housing units in East Jerusalem, a clear snub to the Obama administration. In a response to these developments the Palestinian chief negotiator, Saeb Erekat accused the Netanyahu government of not being serious in its insistence of a two-state solution. He also said that this was the last chance of achieving a two-state solution and if the talks failed, the only option left would be to insist on a shared state, a sure non-starter with the Israelis.

A lot of all this is of course posturing, making political noises ahead of real negotiations that are probably likely to come. But such negotiations will not come as a result of the newly launched talks set to begin later this month. The US proposal of setting the parameters or outline of a permanent agreement and save some of the more difficult issues ? such as Jerusalem and refugees for later ? might work, but it will not happen before the 4 months set up as a target-date have passed.

The real challenge will be when the talks ?fail? without delivering an agreement. For the Palestinians the fact that Abbas and his government is not controlling a large chunk of what will constitute the future Palestine ? Gaza ? is a long-term impediment to any long-term solution. And as long as the conflict between Fatah and Hamas is unresolved, whatever agreement is signed, a Palestinian government will not be able to deliver.

The US hope is that by locking the partners into a plan that clearly states that the long-term goal is a two-state solution and an end-of conflict agreement, it will be possible to handle the foreseeable obstacles in the negotiations regarding the ?core?-issues such as Jerusalem and refugees. And by tying this long-term plan to the successful Dayton-mission and Palestinian Premier Fayyad?s plans for a civil Palestinian infrastructure, it is further hoped that this time around, real progress can be achieved further down the road, even if there is no permanent end-of conflict agreement at the end of the present round of indirect talks.

Share this 

Related Stories

First reported 2 hours ago - Updated 2 hours ago - 1 reports

‘Dig’ pulls up Jerusalem stakes

The NBC program “DIG” has packed up and left Jerusalem as Israel’s conflict with Hamas drags on.The program, from Israeli “Homeland” creator Gideon Raff and “Heroes” creator Tim Kring, has been filming in Israel’s capital since the beginning of the summer ... [Published The Times Of Israel - 2 hours ago]
First reported 15 hours ago - Updated 49 mins ago - 1 reports

After Israel, the next stop for Hamas is the Vatican

All the claims that the Jews are planning to destroy the Al-Aqsa mosque are false. For years it has been protected and guarded by Israel. If they wanted to, the Jews could let Hamas's missiles land in Jerusalem, possibly destroying the mosques on the ... [Published SperoNews - 15 hours ago]
First reported 22 hours ago - Updated 21 hours ago - 1 reports

Arabs, Jews arrested for fighting outside Jerusalem mall

Three Arabs and two Jews were arrested Tuesday afternoon following a street fight outside of the mall in the capital’s Ramot neighborhood, located in northern Jerusalem, police said.While the details of the altercation remain unclear, police said none ... [Published Jerusalem Post - 22 hours ago]
Entities: Jerusalem, Police, Israel
First reported Jul 21 2014 - Updated 22 hours ago - 2 reports

13 Palestinians injured in clashes north of Jerusalem

JERUSALEM (Ma'an) -- Thirteen Palestinians were injured late Monday in clashes with Israeli forces in al-Ram north of Jerusalem, a Ma'an reporter said.Youths threw rocks and empty bottles at Israeli soldiers, who shot live fire, rubber-coated bullets, ... [Published Ma'an News Agency - Jul 22 2014]
First reported Jul 21 2014 - Updated Jul 21 2014 - 1 reports

Rocket sirens heard in Tel Aviv, Jerusalem and across the country

Rockets were fired at Israel in the South and Center shortly before noon on Monday.The rockets set off sirens in Tel Aviv and Jerusalem in a rarer occurrence since the IDF commenced its ground incursion in Gaza and disrupted terror activity from the ... [Published Jerusalem Post - Jul 21 2014]
Entities: Tel Aviv, Jerusalem, Israel
First reported Jul 21 2014 - Updated Jul 21 2014 - 1 reports

Ethiopia: Ethiopian Pilgrims' Journey

Thousands of years of strong connection and a strong bond that cannot be broken by wars or government relationships is the relationship of Ethiopians with Jerusalem. Jerusalem might resemble the 'city of God' for many Ethiopians. The kings who want to ... [Published - Jul 21 2014]
First reported Jul 17 2014 - Updated Jul 17 2014 - 3 reports

Jerusalem Unbound: a City in Conflict

A new book, Jerusalem Unbound , plots the history and examines the underlying factors that make a peace agreement between Israel and the Palestinians so difficult.Written by Professor Mick Dumper, a University of Exeter politics expert with over 25 years ... [Published Exeter University - Jul 17 2014]


sort by: Date | Relevance
Kerry Cites Progress in Gaza Cease-Fire Talks [Published The China Blog - 51 mins ago]
(JERUSALEM) — Offering the first glimmer of hope for a Gaza cease-fire, the United States on Wednesday said negotiations to broker a truce between Israel and Hamas militants are making some progress even if an end to more than two weeks of bloodshed ...
Kerry Cites Progress in Gaza Cease-Fire Talks [Published The Middle East Blog - - 51 mins ago]
(JERUSALEM) — Offering the first glimmer of hope for a Gaza cease-fire, the United States on Wednesday said negotiations to broker a truce between Israel and Hamas militants are making some progress even if an end to more than two weeks of bloodshed ...
AJC Brief Supports Jerusalem Family's U.S. Pass... [Published PR Newswire: Policy & Public Interest - 17 hours ago]
NEW YORK, July 22, 2014 /PRNewswire-USNewswire/ -- For the third time AJC has filed an amicus brief in support of a Jerusalem family seeking to list Israel as their son's place of birth in his U.S. passport. The case, Zivotofsky v. the Secretary of ...
Israel Declares Soldier Hamas Says Holds in Gaz... [Published Bloomberg via Google News - 20 hours ago]
Israel Declares Soldier Hamas Says Holds in Gaza Missing Bloomberg To contact the reporters on this story: Saud Abu Ramadan in Jerusalem at sramadan@ bloomberg .net; Calev Ben-David in Jerusalem at cbendavid@ bloomberg .net; Sangwon Yoon in Cairo ...
occupied Palestinian territory: Emirates Red Cr... [Published ReliefWeb - Latest Updates - Jul 21 2014]
Source: Emirates News AgencyCountry: occupied Palestinian territory The Emirates Red Crescent, ERC, has implemented phase one of its 'Basmat Al Nuwar' project, set-up to aid underprivileged families in the Old City of Jerusalem in an effort to improve ...
1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 ...


sort by: Date | Relevance
Netanyahu vows to fight on [Published Reuters Video: Top News - Jul 10 2014]
Supporters of beaten Florida teen demand justice [Published Reuters Video: Top News - Jul 07 2014]
Jerusalem tense prior to funeral of slain Pales... [Published Reuters Video: Top News - Jul 04 2014]
The Tragedy of Collective Punishment [Published Slate Magazine - Jul 03 2014]
Video shows Bieber making more racial slurs, Ro... [Published Reuters Video: Entertainment - Jun 04 2014]
1 2

Press Releases

sort by: Date | Relevance
magicJack Reports First Quarter 2014 Financial ... [Published GlobeNewswire: Acquisitions News - May 12 2014]
Contact Us

Freebase CC-BY Some image thumbnails are sourced from Freebase, licensed under CC-BY

Copyright (C) 2014 Silobreaker Ltd. All rights reserved.
The selection and placement of stories and images on any Silobreaker page are determined automatically by a computer program.
The time or date displayed reflects when an article was added to or updated in Silobreaker.